How to Build Real Attention Without Entertaining Your Kids or Class

One of my favorite movies is the most boring to explain. There are no raging beasts, no intergalactic overlords, no rag-tag team of superheroes altering the space-time continuum and building an interstellar space bridge. It's just151 minutes of a solitary man stranded on a distant planet, planting potatoes and communicating with Earth on a whiteboard. And when I put it that way, it doesn't sound so exciting.

So why do I keep watching it? Because that lone astronaut faces difficulty after difficulty. That's why I pay attention.

Can you see how that relates to education?

The Modern Temptation: Make Everything Exciting

In modern learning, there is a huge push to make lessons sparkle with creativity. All classroom or homeschool activities must be entertaining and educationally rich. We're told that we need to add games and make learning fun. Digital presentations must be movie-quality, with animated slides, video clips, and interesting transitions. We should keep students on the move to ensure they aren't bored. Every single moment needs to be engaging and light up all five senses.

That's exhausting! And as a parent or teacher... that's impossible. It's too much pressure. It takes too much time and thought. You can not constantly invent new gimmicks to compete for a child's attention. And if you are, you're doing education wrong.

You are assuming that students need to be excited to learn. They don't. In fact, excitement can do just the opposite. Classroom and cognitive research on the learning process has shown us something we didn't expect. Excitement doesn't mean students are interested. Excitement doesn't produce deep learning. In fact, when students are stimulated, nothing feels challenging enough to matter.

What Really Drives Attention?

What actually holds attention is not constant excitement but meaningful difficulty.

Our brains were meant to survive situations. Humans are wired to notice almost solvable problems; challenges that are just beyond our understanding are like puzzles that are begging to be completed. If the puzzle is too easy, our brains dismiss it. If it's too hard, our brains reject it. We instictually protect ourselves from making a terrible mistake.

But right between 'too easy' and 'too hard' is the sweet spot. Our system thrives on that little powerful Zone of Proximal Development.

What is it? It's that space between what a learner can do on their own and what they can achieve with just a little help or guidance. It's a place where we understand that we are smart enough to overcome a challenge, but we need a little hint to help us get past it. It's the place that connects us to a wiser person and, at the same time, magnifies our independent spirit.

Lev Vygotsky named that magical space. His Zone of Proximal Development has been influencing educators of all kinds since the 1930's. Sadly, in our modern world, his lessons have been drowned out or forgotten altogether by pressured parents and teachers who are doing their absolute best to survive each day and teach their students something valuable.

How Do I Use It?

First off, realise that your homeschool table or classroom is a place of deep, meaningful, rich education. You are not a cruise ship entertainment director. You are the sage, wise guru with a rich and diverse life. You were put here to impart your wisdom.

Next, realise that the mind does not absorb information like a sponge.

The mind grows by resolving a problem. By eliminating the uncomfortable tension that arises when there is something that needs to be done, but they just barely can't grasp how to do it.

Start creating opportunities where students encounter something slightly beyond their grasp; a situation where their current understanding is almost working, but not quite. A task that gets their brain to imagine possible solutions, adjust and retry ideas, and look for patterns, a task where the hints and clues you give them lead to a solution or conclusion.

And when that solution hits, that... that is learning!

That's when the lesson sticks.

That's when you've made a difference.

If learning is always packed with fun and entertainment, the students are being fed. It looks good on the outside, but there are no Eurika moments. No big surprises. No sense of accomplishment.

Entertaining activities are cheating our students out of that.

But How Do I Do That?

I know what your next argument is. I've taught in a variety of situations. I understand.

It sounds amazing, but it also sounds impossible. How do you know exactly what will challenge them? How do you target that Zone of Proximity with pinpoint accuracy? What activities can I use that don't require rewriting every lesson?

You don't need to invent a new curriculum to create a challenge. In reality, most lessons already contain the raw material. Just rearrange the order so the problem appears before the explanation.

Let's start with this:

1. Reframe your role: You are now a Designer of Challenges. Your job is to place students in an uncomfortable situation. It has a solution, it's just not clear to them.

   • You are NASA, and you just sent your astronauts to Mars.
     

2. Start with the problem: Give students the situation before the information. Let them look at it, wrtestle with it, and even misunderstand it.

   • Your astronauts are stranded. They need to take stock of what they have and imagine how they will survive.
     

3. Now teach them: Tell the students what they need to know. Show them the tools, the information, the facts that will help them reach a solution. This is where you teach the lesson. Let them take notes.

   • Your astronauts gather their tools and supplies and build themselves a survival shelter. They start growing potatoes. They communicate with you via whiteboard.
     

4. Make struggle and failure normal: Let your students try something, perhaps fail, and be confused. Then discuss it. This is the perfect time to talk about what they are learning.

   • Your stranded astronauts have stayed alive this long, but still can't figure out how to get home. You two establish radio contact. It's their job to keep you updated on their progress.
     

5. Don't rescue: Resist the urge to rescue your students. Don't leave them stranded; you will give them hints along the way, but not the answer.

   • You are NASA; you can give them information when they ask, but your rescue team is 140 million miles away.
     

6. Let them find the answers: When you've given them enough support, your students will discover the answers and solutions. They will make the connections you need them to, and the learning process will come full circle.

   • Your astronauts found the old lander, stripped it down to the bare essentials, and took a wild risk by launching themselves into the unknown, knowing full well this was their final solution.
     

7. Reflect and celebrate: Conclude the problem-solving cycle with a discussion. Reflect on what they were unsure about, what they thought would happen, what they tried, and how they solved the problem.

   • Catch those astronauts the second they break out of the atmosphere. Reach out to them and pull them in. Assure them they are safe and successful.

Download here.

Here are Problems for Every Kind of Lesson

• Ask for a Prediction: What would happen if...? What should this person do next and why? Which method will...?
  

• Show a Pattern: Show a series of similar images, numbers, words, or events. Then ask them to identify the rule. Why are these similar? Why are these different? What connects all of these things?
  

• Present an Error: Present a solution to a problem that has a critical error in it. Will this work? Why or why not?
  

• Present an Alternative: Present two nearly identical items, situations, solutions, or stories.  Why are they different, and why does it matter?
  

• Give them a Limitation: Give students a goal, but limit how they can reach it. Constrain forces creativity. Write only using words that start with.... Build something only using.... This culture only had ______. How did they...?
  

• Flip the Problem: State the solution first. How did that happen? Why did that happen? What led up to this moment? How did I get that answer?
  

• Ranking Systems: Present several possibilities and ask students to order them based on some reasoning that requires opinion: usefulness, reasonability, impact, value, data, or importance.
  

• Odd one Out: Present several possibilities, items, or facts. Include one that seems plausible but does not match the others. Which one doesn’t belong and why?
  

• Incomplete Information: Give students a task or a goal and purposely leave out an important element, tool, or fact. Students identify gaps in their knowledge or a system and either look for alternatives or address the issue.

Download here.